Shivam Metal Shaper :I.T.A No. 123/(Asr)/2017: 15-09-2017
Cases Followed
P&H High Court in KS Bhatia 269 ITR 577
Chhattisgarh High Court in Roop Chand Tharani 249 CTR 326
ITAT Asr Harpreet Singh Gulati ITA 317/ASR/2013
PMS Diesel ITA 317/ASR/2013
Kashmir Steel Rolling Mills ITA 509/Asr/2016 dtd 04-09-2017
P&H High Court in KS Bhatia 269 ITR 577
“……………..in the absence of a definite finding that the case of assessee comes within the provisions of section 145(1) that it was not possible for Assessing Officer to make additions to the gross profit. It has been further held that mere fact that profits as compared to earlier year were lower does not warrant an addition…………………….”
Chhattisgarh High Court in Roop Chand Tharani 249 CTR 326
“………………without pointing out any specific mistake in the books of account, the Assessing Officer cannot reject the books of account………………..”
Kashmir Steel Rolling Mills ITA 509/Asr/2016 dtd 04-09-2017
“……….the assessee was not able to produce some of the expenditure vouchers…………… a disallowance @ 1/10 of these expense is being made………………….. The Assessing Officer in its assessment order dated 28.12.2006 had not rejected the books of account of the assessee and there is no finding given by the Assessing Officer in its assessment order that the books of account are not reliable or unverifiable…………………. there is no question of making any ad-hoc disallowance towards consumption of bagasse…………………….”